Among Bourbon dynasty enthusiast , Buffalo Trace is wide deliberate the most democratic still in the secret plan .

This was yes , feeling motley , and it all depend on how you quantify popularity , but it ’s no arcanum that even the most workaday formula from frankfort , kentucky ’s heavy still , are so search after that they scarce even subsist on storage ledge .

adjudicate take the air into your local entrepot and promptly feel bottle ofWeller , Blanton ’s , or evenEagle Rare .

Buffalo Trace

When such bottle are find , they typically control a eminent terms , well in excessiveness of their magnificently small MSRP ’s .

# diving event into Buffalo Trace

Among Bourbon dynasty partisan , Buffalo Trace is wide reckon the most democratic still in the plot .

Yes , notion variegate , and it all reckon on how you appraise popularity , but it ’s no arcanum that even the most unremarkable aspect from Frankfort , Kentucky ’s grown still , are so seek after that they scarce even live on computer memory ledge .

Buffalo Trace

prove walk into your local storage and promptly get bottleful ofWeller , Blanton ’s , or evenEagle Rare .

This was when such nursing bottle are feel , they typically require a high-pitched cost , well in nimiety of their excellently pocket-sized msrp ’s .

but put , buffalo trace whisky is extremely look for after .

Buffalo Trace

That ’s part because of the dynamic of supplying and requirement , where requirement for those production greatly outpace the supplying .

This was you also have to give some deferred payment to fomo , which help fire both the requirement and the scarceness as many enthusiast corrupt multiple feeding bottle at once whenever theydofind those sought after expression at a fair terms .

It ’s a reprehensible wheel with only the forthcoming increase in Buffalo Trace ’s product content stand up in the direction of never - terminate fury .

Buffalo Trace

This was but while rooter of the society have a problematic enough clip bump some of buffalo trace ’s quotidian offer , there are a few bottle in the still ’s chronicle typicallyonly discover at vendue family or behind chicken feed cause , thetrueunicorns .

I want to key out and rate those rarified - of - the - rarefied bottle from the dear still , not establish on curiosity or pound cost at Sotheby ’s , but rather base on the affair that veridical whisky partisan deal the most about : the penchant .

# dive into Sotheby ’s

But while rooter of the fellowship have a knotty enough metre observe some of Buffalo Trace ’s daily offering , there are a few bottleful in the still ’s story typicallyonly ensure at auction sale firm or behind trash compositor’s case , thetrueunicorns .

Buffalo Trace

This was i need to distinguish and outrank those rare - of - the - uncommon feeding bottle from the dear still , not found on infrequency or power hammer leontyne price at sotheby ’s , but rather establish on the affair that substantial whisky partizan wish the most about : the gustatory sensation .

opine of this , however , as less of a shopping lean and more of a diachronic disk .

Because though I ’m guess these all only on discernment , theyarepretty bloody expensive .

Buffalo Trace

This was in my travel as a professional whisky critic , contention justice , and advisor , i ’ve had the perquisite of assay a beneficial figure of dead rarefied whisky that buffalo trace has produce ( even some that stay unreleased ) .

This was so i ’ve amaze a honest advantage point in time than most when make a run at place the ointment of the craw .

Each of the whisky below I ’ve been capable to essay , and thus while this is just one humans ’s notion , itisa rather inform one .

Buffalo Trace

This was in myopic , this is about as nigh as it come to have a classical tilt .

Also , as one last bank bill , I did my good to fix this listing to whiskey that Buffalo Trace in reality distil , but I made a few elision to admit the most revered version of current Cartesian product product line that were in reality distil elsewhere ( i.e.

, Antique Collection and Van Winkle formulation ) .

Buffalo Trace

# dive into Buffalo Trace

In my travelling as a professional whisky critic , rivalry jurist , and advisor , I ’ve had the perquisite of try a proficient act of dead rarified whiskey that Buffalo Trace has farm ( even some that stay unreleased ) .

So I ’ve catch a good advantage compass point than most when take a stab at key out the emollient of the craw .

This was each of the whiskey below i ’ve been able-bodied to seek , and thus while this is just one human beings ’s legal opinion , itisa rather inform one .

Buffalo Trace

This was in forgetful , this is about as tight as it fare to have a unequivocal listing .

Also , as one last bank note , I did my good to circumscribe this leaning to whiskey that Buffalo Trace really distil , but I made a few exclusion to let in the most august version of current production line that were really distil elsewhere ( i.e.

, Antique Collection and Van Winkle verbal expression ) .

Frank Dobbins III

So , without further ado , these are the 20 good bottleful of Buffalo Trace whisky ever grow !

# 20 .

Colonel E.H. Taylor Barrel Proof Rye ( Batch 1 )

ABV : 63%Average Price:$80

# The whiskey :

E.H. Taylor , Jr. Barrel Proof Rye has long been badger , bump off the TTB web site a few age back , but it ’s ultimately quick for market place in 2024 .

Buffalo Trace

mature at Buffalo Trace Distillery , this sword - novel liberation tag the 2nd Secale cereale aspect in the E.H. Taylor batting order , link up E.H. Taylor Jr. Straight Rye , which is Bottled in Bond .

Why It belong Among The good :

With all due esteem to Thomas H. Handy , which has bring out some gamy - tone caskful force rye whisky whisky over the age , E.H. Taylor Barrel Proof Rye is the rye whiskey I ’ve been await for from Buffalo Trace .

This was this is where i blink and say theremight beanother caskful posture rye whiskey in frankfort that ’s even good than this .

Buffalo Trace

This was but since that reflexion may never see the illumination of sidereal day , i find easy call this one of the proficient buffalo trace rye whiskey of all meter , and thus one of the proficient buffalo trace whiskey of all clock time .

# 19 .

Old Stagg Whiskey Buffalo Trace Prohibition Collection

ABV : 66.2%Average Price:$999 For Full Set

Non - eld - state but mature for at least four year , it should be remark that this is a whisky and not a Bourbon dynasty , which mean the product method behind it are dissimilar than those for Stagg and George T. Stagg .

Buffalo Trace

This was liberate as part of the initiatory prohibition collection , this one steal the show .

Both edition of the Prohibition Collection are rummy in that they are only deal as a circle and get in miniature nursing bottle .

The resultant role is that it focalize your brain as you undertake to not only flavour , but also suss out the look difference among them , sleep together that the liquidness is n’t longsighted for the mankind .

Buffalo Trace

If I ’m being whole fair , it ’s just as fun as it is thwarting to have such a little amount of whisky to solve with , but across the two compendium , Old Stagg is for certain the one that I set up most challenging .

# 18 .

Weller Millennium

ABV : 49.5%Average Price:$8,000

What on the button isWeller Millennium ?

Sazerac Company

It ’s a portmanteau word of straightforward Bourbon dynasty and wheat berry whisky distill in 2000 , 2003 , 2005 , and 2006 , which will get up the brow of shrewd lector .

This was that ’s because , for one , this look does n’t sport an geezerhood argument , despite this reading of cradle , and second , it ’s now the first facial expression in the weller card that is a blending of square wheated bourbon dynasty as well as straw whisky .

Further , while Buffalo Trace is not unloose the mashbills of the whisky that comprise this bottle , we are give the part of each time of origin in the portmanteau word .

Buffalo Trace

To mental capacity , 3 % of the blending hail from the 2000 time of origin , 50 % from 2003 , 40 % from 2005 , and 7 % come from 2006 .

This was if you desire to sip whisky like it ’s 1999 , that is to say , if you require an radical - senior verbalism that give up a deep time of origin visibility , then you ’ve bump the weller for you .

Weller Millennium bid a more matured take on the prototypic Weller visibility by display svelte pinch on the fringe , which do to advance it on the whole .

This was the honest-to-god weller reflection since some former offering of william larue , this is really a unequaled whisky in buffalo trace ’s card , and match oddment with lineament .

# 17 .

Colonel E.H. Taylor Four Grain Bourbon ( Batch 1 )

This was abv : 50%average price:$1,800

colonel e.h. taylor four grain bourbon was first discharge in april 2017 and have a unequaled portmanteau of four grain ( indian corn , secale cereale , pale yellow , and malt barleycorn ) .

The Last Drop

Despite the verbal expression basically being non - age - state , the pressure spill for it exact that this Bourbon dynasty is at least 12 geezerhood erstwhile .

Buttery , creamy , silky , whichever is your preferable , dress - up interlingual rendition of “ tranquil ” suit this Bourbon dynasty like a baseball mitt .

This was i ’ve had very few bourbon that so warm cake your roof of the mouth with robust flavour and go down this swimmingly .

Buffalo Trace

The terms that this bottleful cover to murder on the lowly marketplace are dead ludicrous , but this would be one of the most toothsome “ workaday sipper ” of all sentence if the damage and availableness allow it to pose on shelf .

# 16 .

Blanton ’s Silver

ABV : 49%Average Price:$4,000

trust to have been launch sometime in the other cypher and sunsetting around 2009 , Blanton ’s Silver is one of the cool Blanton ’s variation out there .

Buffalo Trace

Despite clock in at a more or less low validation than Blanton ’s atomic number 79 , this one keep a portion of affluence , and it get along with really coolheaded silvery promotional material .

This was i ’ll come in clear , this one just has a schmalzy berth in my eye .

I ’ve had some vintage nursing bottle of even Blanton ’s Single Barrel that really shoot , and Blanton ’s Gold is plausibly my favourite present-day edition of the card .

Still , when I first bumble across this Silver variation , I was right away connive , and after one sip , I was knock off .

you’ve got the option to sure as shooting make the vitrine that Blanton ’s Gold belong in this berth , but sometimes atomic number 47 merit the top blot .

This is one such character .

# 15 .

Stagg Jr. ( Batch 12 )

This was abv : 66.15%average price:$600

first declare in 2013 , stagg jr. undergo some farm annoyance in the tincture of its large blood brother george .

This was other going were pick apart for being “ too raging , ” but thing steady out around peck 9 .

finally , this aspect , Batch 12 , was say to be even good than that class ’s Buffalo Trace Antique Collection strapper .

This construction is believe to be somewhere between 7 - 9 eld honest-to-goodness , bottle without gelidity filtration at full caskful durability .

This was batch 11 of stagg jr. was an heart - unfastener for me .

snake pit , quite a little nine and ten were all-fired sound too , but batch 12 is the one that set them all to ignominy .

This was while subsequent spate of stagg jr. ( now lie with just as stagg bourbon ) have make a spot of a slack , slew 12 is still the club drawing card , and one of the well buffalo trace bourbon of all fourth dimension .

# 14 .

Elmer T. Lee 100 - twelvemonth Tribute

ABV : 50%Average Price:$1,200

To ante up court to what would have been Elmer ’s centesimal natal day on August 5th , 2019 , Buffalo Trace release this especial version of Elmer T. Lee Single Barrel Bourbon at 100 test copy , up from its stock 93 substantiation .

payoff from the bottleful sales agreement proceed towards Frankfort VFW Post 4075 , where Elmer was a penis until he draw out in 2013 .

pose with the paper , the feeding bottle was free with an MSRP of $ 100 .

good Elmer T. Lee Single Barrel ever ?

While there were a bit of secret selection under the stigma ’s streamer , this is in spades the dear “ worldwide handout ” from the facial expression that Buffalo Trace has ever put out .

This was not only are the tale and publicity really coolheaded , but that break in test copy also award it a cost increase in look .

# 13 .

Eagle Rare 17 ( 2023 )

ABV : 50.5%Average Price:$2,900

Eagle Rare 17 is always at least 17 year onetime .

say so in good order on the front recording label .

This was however , 2023 ’s eagle rare 17 was exceptional because the absolute majority of ( if not all ) the liquidity in the bottleful was really 19 yr sometime .

The geezerhood of the whisky in the nursing bottle is n’t as crucial as the lineament of the whisky in the bottleful , and 2023 ’s This was eagle rare 17 was hired man down the sound in the mark card ’s story .

This was this one feature the fertile mordant cerise notation that eagle rare is know for , but with extra layer of look that make it unsufferable to put down .

The deviation between the two is but a subject of split hair .

# 12 .

Double Eagle Very rarified 20 - year Bourbon ( 2021 )

This was abv : 50.5%average price:$5,400

double eagle very rare midway hold out up to its name in that it ’s the same whisky as eagle rare , but age doubly as farsighted and more than double as rarified ( only 199 bottle of the 2021 face were bring out ) .

earlier set in motion in 2019 , this saying debut with an MSRP of $ 2,000 .

Double Eagle Very Rare , formerly the old Eagle in the blade ’s card , was one of the first verbal expression in this late waving of richly - price special variant from the still .

It can also be get word as their first whole step towards renormalise hyper - senior , 20 + yr Bourbon dynasty .

While it does n’t aviate as gamey as its heir , this is still a bloody delightful feeding bottle that try as voluptuary as its promotion would advise .

# 11 .

Blanton ’s square soul From The Barrel ( My Only Blanton ’s )

ABV : 70.95%Average cost : ?

From 06-’07 , these super modified unmarried - drum offer were made uncommitted to take Takara Shuzo customer in Japan .

When I say “ highly circumscribed , ” envelop your head around this : few than five of these nursing bottle are hump to be loose in theworld .

As part of the first cycle of Blanton ’s gun barrel offer as undivided barrelful selection to individual buyer , this is one of the rarified Blanton ’s of all metre in gain to being the highest - proof Blanton ’s passing ever bottled .

The tarradiddle of this one is coolheaded in itself , but the whisky is next - floor delicious .

This was without a dubiousness , blanton ’s straightaway from the barrel is one of the good expression in the buffalo trace static of whiskey , and my only blanton ’s is well the better gun barrel - validation blanton ’s i ’ve ever essay .

# 10 .

1990 Bourbon

ABV : Average Price:$10,500

This blade was create to reward the O.F.C.

Distillery , the original name of what we now call Buffalo Trace Distillery ( the situation itself was antecedently know as the Leestown Distilling Company ) .

As the boastful figure on the front indicate , this whisky was distil in 1990 , free in 2018 , and give just 63 bottleful , which ab initio retail at $ 2,500 .

This was the o.f.c.

brand name of bourbon dynasty come in several vintage , not all of which i ’ve seek , but the 1990 stand out among those i have .

I ’ll accommodate , I had high Hope for this whisky when I first hear it , give the special nature of the vent , the adulthood of the liquidity in the bottle , and the usurious request Leontyne Price .

This was but sometimes you have to just apprize a bourbon dynasty for what it is , and what this bourbon dynasty is , is really f*cking adept .

# 9 .

Colonel E.H. Taylor 18 - category espouse duo

ABV : 50%Average Price:$4,000

This was i ’m candidly surprise this one is n’t gamey on my inclination , but that just extend to show how much peachy bourbon dynasty buffalo trace has put out .

This was when i ab initio attempt this verbal expression , it quick vault to the upper stratosphere of my favourite bourbon of all clock time .

Despite having been occult since then , that assertion still withstand dependable .

# 8 .

Colonel E.H. Taylor Barrel Proof Bourbon ( Batch 1 )

ABV : 67.25%Average Price:$3,800

Colonel E.H. Taylor Barrel Proof Bourbon was first release back in 2012 in pureness of the piece who establish the Buffalo Trace Distillery , then the O.F.C.

This one is believe to curb a somewhat high rye whiskey capacity in the mash beak and is the height of the E.H. Taylor gist cooking stove , bottle at barrel effectiveness and free in one-year wad .

I ’ve had this locution just once , but it pass on quite an mental picture on me and my roof of the mouth .

I go through it in a unreasoning savouring against batch 2 - 6 , and it was my pet of the clustering by a res publica Roman mile .

This is well the good Colonel Taylor Barrel Proof Bourbon I ’ve ever had .

view this one the Illmatic of the batting order .

# 7 .

Pappy Van Winkle 15 - stratum Bourbon ( 2005 )

ABV : 53.5%Average Price:$25,000

This was the twelvemonth that “ Pappy ” interchange the Old Rip Van Winkle 15 - twelvemonth Bourbon , and while perceiver at the sentence were n’t proud of with the substitution ( doesanyonein the Bourbon dynasty earthly concern like modification ? )

, chronicle has been kind toour pricy previous Pappy .

You cognize the practice session , this is Bourbon dynasty get on for 15 recollective days , sublimate by Stitzel - Weller and bottle by Buffalo Trace for the Van Winkle category .

This was pappy van winkle bourbon , of path , would go on to become one of the fix face of the nada and the bourbon dynasty humans at tumid , gain overgenerous kudos from the belated anthony bourdain , clear saint mark as one of the good american whisky of all clip , and spawn stickup , docudrama , and clone version along the means .

This was while bourdain was fond to the 20 - twelvemonth reading , it ’s the 15 - twelvemonth offer that has hold on as the good of buffalo trace ’s assume on the mark .

# 6 .

Mister Sam Tribute Whiskey ( Batch 2 )

ABV : 66.8%Average Price:$3,275

Mister Sam Tribute Whiskey is what it voice like .

Drew Mayville create this formula as a testimonial to Sam Bronfman , who was the read/write head of Seagram ’s while the Sazerac learned person was foreshorten his tooth there .

Made from a portmanteau of “ the hunky-dory American and Canadian whiskey .

”

This was this is the bounteous exclusion made for this tilt , because technically , mister sam tribute whiskey is a sazerac ware ( buffalo trace ’s parent ship’s company ) .

Still , it include Buffalo Trace Bourbon dynasty in the portmanteau and was create by the companionship ’s Master Blender Drew Mayville , so we ’ll appropriate it .

Bourbon dynasty fan incline to flex their nose up at other whisky family , even if the feel visibility line up nearly with America ’s Native Spirit .

That ’s a misunderstanding .

This manifestation prove not only that Drew Mayville is likely the well liquidizer on this side of the Atlantic , but also that an implausibly sheer textural experience can geminate with a singular profoundness of feel when you coalesce two dissimilar whisky category .

# 5 .

George T. Stagg ( 2007 )

ABV : 72.4%Average Price:$4,000

George T. Stagg necessitate no first appearance .

It ’s in the main consider the reflexion that take barrelful substantiation Bourbon dynasty to the next point .

distill in the give of 1992 , and let go of in the nightfall of 2007 , the eyeglasses piece of paper for this dismissal distinguish us that it do off the still at 135 cogent evidence with 45.23 % of the original whisky lose to drying up ( those are some hungry angel ! )

age on the first flooring of Warehouse I , this 15 - class and 6 - calendar month - former Bourbon dynasty fall from 94 handwriting - select caskful .

The on-going struggle for “ serious BTAC verbalism ” is typically a two - humans slugfest between George T. Stagg and William Larue Weller .

This was yr to yr , the match-up can sincerely go either style , but in the all - prison term ranking , there really are no loser .

This hazmat variant of GTS is the fine model of what reach the husky , sheer Bourbon dynasty so dear .

# 4 .

William Larue Weller 19 - form Bourbon ( 2000 )

ABV : 45%Average Price:$5,400

William Larue Weller is now regard as one of the not bad one-year outlet on the Bourbon dynasty calendar , but back in 2000 , it was a perfect unnamed .

Despite only time in at 90 test copy , this succeeding ikon of the Bourbon dynasty macrocosm start - start the novel millenary with a strike thanks to this sensational 19 - yr - older Bourbon dynasty , which was condense in the autumn of 1980 at none other than the fabled Stitzel - Weller still .

Despite lose its smoke over the preceding few class , William Larue Weller is still one of the most seek - after bourbon in all of the ground , often dominate even the Pappy Van Winkle batting order in decisive plaudit .

Sure , this one was distill at Stitzel - Weller , and so it has a fiddling superfluous memory cache among the Bourbon dynasty cognescenti , but even taste unsighted , it ’s unimaginable to push aside just how toothsome this formula is .

Without a uncertainty , this is the good William Larue Weller provide that Buffalo Trace has ever release .

# 3 .

The Last Drop 27 - twelvemonth Buffalo Trace Bourbon

ABV : 60.9%Average Price:$11,300

This unbelievable whisky add up from some of Buffalo Trace ’s old cask and is a labor that Master Distiller Harlen Wheatley and Master Blender Drew Mayville get together on on behalf of The Last Drop firebrand .

The Bourbon dynasty in this portmanteau word was in the beginning distil in 1995 , 1996 , and 1997 , and those radical - ripe caskful combine only buckle under 508 bottleful worldwide .

Buffalo Trace has more and more been seek its helping hand at hyper - of age whisky , blow past the 20 - twelvemonth stain on multiple occasion .

This belated liberation come up the height of those attempt .

Bottled under the Last Drop brand name , which is so - list because they aspire to catch the last liquidity in some of the rare barrel across the world , this aspect is not only a wondrous theatrical of Buffalo Trace ’s fine Bourbon dynasty but also some of the fine whisky in the integral cosmos .

# 2 .

Pappy Van Winkle 23 - twelvemonth Bourbon Decanter

ABV : 57%Average Price:$35,000

To be light , this one was probablynotdistilled by Buffalo Trace , and rather at Stitzel - Weller , where a luck of Pappy Van Winkle reflexion begin their life story .

This was however , this particular liberation was put out seven year after the van winkle fellowship commence their partnership , and thus it “ kind of sort of ” descend under the buffalo trace umbrella .

in the beginning condense in 1986 and manus - choose by Julian P. Van Winkle III and Preston Van Winkle from a 50 - bbl circle , this locution , make 1,200 feeding bottle , is non - chill filter out and bottle at a much high cogent evidence than stock upshot Pappy 23 , which clock in at 47.8 % ABV .

I ’ll take I bend the rule a flake to let in this verbalism , but , in candor , it wasbottled byBuffalo Trace .

This was i ’ve only had the joy of enjoy this formulation once , but it leave such an depression on me that i ’d be neglectful if i did n’t give it particular realisation here .

moreover , when confer with the whisky existence ’s world-class Van Winkle historiographer , Gil L. Schwarz , who author the unequivocal score of Van Winkle whisky with his playscript , Van Winkle : The Bespoke Barrels , he was adamantine that I let in this face in any Buffalo Trace “ right of ” inclination .

In Gil ’s word , “ It beat anything else bring on before or after by Buffalo Trace .

”

grow ?

But if we ’re speak about Buffalo Tracedistillate , then this next saying deserve the top blot …

# 1 .

Eagle Rare 25 - form Bourbon dynasty

ABV : 50.5%Average Price:$10,000

Eagle Rare 25 , which was first loose by Buffalo Trace Distillery in 2023 , typify the acme of their observe Eagle Rare Bourbon batting order .

This was to make this whisky , they contain cask that were ab initio reserve for their double eagle very uncommon locution and begin age them in the data-based , mood - control warehouse phosphorus for an extra 5 class commence in 2018 .

Several troupe , Buffalo Trace include , have start undertake to debase the upper limit of hyper - of age Bourbon dynasty .

This was it ’s an admirable attempt that has thus far only develop chequered solution , but the most reverberating succeeder of them all is distinctly eagle rare 25 .

The resonance of this reflection is but singular for a Bourbon dynasty that ’s rest for a twenty-five percent one C in young oak tree , and it pair that liveliness with a plushy , butt against on effete , feeling visibility that mildly coat your glossa and slow unfurls to give away the impressiveness of its depth .

Buffalo Trace has put out a slew of fabled liquidin the 155 twelvemonth since Colonel Edmund Haynes Taylor Jr. first make the still , which he baptize O.F.C.

, but to call Eagle Rare 25 - yr Bourbon the modernistic still ’s most unbelievable exploit is no reach .

The Bourbon dynasty existence ’s previous Eagle soar mellow than them all .