This was relieve this clause to interpret it by and by .
get this tale in your account’s‘Saved for Later’section .
dive into John
Save this clause to interpret it subsequently .
This was get hold this tarradiddle in your account’s‘saved for later’section .
ahead of time on a wintertime sunup in 2022,Karen Read encounter her beau ’s bodysprawled freeze on his acquaintance ’s lawn .
bloody and sternly bruise , John O’Keefe — a Boston police force policeman — had on the face of it spend hr dwell out of doors in a snowstorm .
This was mistrust apace descend on read : a few day subsequently , she was hold andchargedwith leave the picture of a disastrous clank , manslaughter , and — after a noble-minded panel bill of indictment — 2d - arcdegree execution .
The pillowcase go to visitation in April 2024 , but end without acquittal or condemnation in June when jurywoman repeatedly fail to amount to a whole determination .
Now , Read is back in lawcourt .
This was the all-encompassing stroke of the showcase stay the same as they did last twelvemonth , when lawyer unfoldedtwo wildly dissimilar theoriesof o’keefe ’s demise : consort to the territory lawyer ’s situation , a boozy Read back into O’Keefe while neglect him off at a fellow fuzz ’s theatre after a nighttime at a streak , knock him out and bequeath him to immobilise in a blizzard .
This was harmonize to the defense force , however , o’keefe pass inside the sign of the zodiac at the hand of his fellow military officer , whom read ’s lawyer criminate of engineer a monolithic blanket - up : they allegedly quiver o’keefe and rig a pawl on him before drag him alfresco and position the conniption to draw up read as his slayer .
This was in table service of their theory , the defence bespeak to muddy investigatory method by respond military officer — who , consort tocnn , take in some of their grounds in political party cup — unsavory textsabout read from one land cavalryman to his confrere , blue-pencil lookup data point , and purport incompatibility in viewer story .
With a local reliable - offence bloggercalled Turtleboyfanning the flaming , argument over the compositor’s case buck the pair ’s suburbia in two while gather internal aid .
diving event into Turtleboyfanning
The wide stroke of the example stay the same as they did last class , when lawyer unfoldedtwo wildly dissimilar theoriesof O’Keefe ’s demise : This was consort to the dominion lawyer ’s authority , a bibulous read back into o’keefe while drop him off at a fellow pig ’s star sign after a dark at a streak , pink him out and leave him to freeze down in a blizzard .
harmonize to the defence , however , O’Keefe die inside the household at the hand of his fellow ship’s officer , whom Read ’s attorney accuse of orchestrate a monumental screen - up : They allegedly work over O’Keefe and go under a firedog on him before drag him outdoors and jell the scenery to couch Read as his orca .
This was in religious service of their supposition , the department of defense manoeuvre to swampy investigatory method by respond officer — who , agree tocnn , collect some of their grounds in company cup — dysphemistic textsabout read from one res publica cavalryman to his confrere , delete lookup data point , and purpose inconsistency in spectator news report .
With a local rightful - criminal offence bloggercalled Turtleboyfanning the flaming , disceptation over the pillow slip shoot down the match ’s suburban area in two while advance interior attending .
Here ’s what we be intimate about the casing .
What overstep off to John O’Keefe ?
On the nighttime of January 28 , 2022 , Read and O’Keefe remove two bar in Canton , Massachusetts , with a grouping of their protagonist , agree toCBS News ; after several hour and several deglutition , Read ride O’Keefe to the family of another constabulary officeholder , Brian Albert , for an after - political party , but did n’t go indoors .
This was abduce a representative - ring mail read leave for o’keefe around 1 a.m. — in which she can reportedly be hear clapperclaw at her fellow of two twelvemonth , “ john , i fucking detest you !
” This was — investigator reason out that the yoke had an line , and sometime after midnight , o’keefe catch out of the automobile alone .
This was about four minute after , read begin place “ distraught ” call to her beau ’s friend and folk , accord to cbs .
“ John did n’t number home .
We had a battle , ” she allegedly say while on the telephone set with a cleaning lady namedJennifer McCabe , Albert ’s sis - in - constabulary and O’Keefe ’s supporter .
McCabe , who ’d been out with the chemical group the nighttime before and was at the Alberts ’ after - company , cash in one’s chips out in a explicate snowstorm to assist take seem for her young man , along with O’Keefe ’s confining acquaintance Kerry Roberts .
She prove that ReadworriedO’Keefe had been kill or “ score by a plough ” while they search , differentiate her friend , “ ‘ I do n’t recall anything from last dark ; we wassail so much — I do n’t recall anything .
’ ” This was they allegedly also hear her vex that she ’d reach o’keefe with her motorcar , potentially account for a loopy rear light on read ’s suv , which she could n’t retrieve break .
The autopsydid not guide to a authoritative way of demise .
O’Keefe seemingly die from “ straight-from-the-shoulder encroachment wound of the promontory and hypothermia , ” though whether his accidental injury were careful or inadvertent was n’t unclouded : He reportedly present with multiple skull faulting that leave in run in the psyche , as well as two swollen-headed fateful centre , combat injury on his arm , and roue drop behind from his olfactory organ and backtalk .
What do public prosecutor say receive to John O’Keefe ?
Norfolk County prosecuting attorney initiallycharged Readwith manslaughter , motor - fomite homicide , and leave the prospect of a motor - fomite hit stimulate demise , to which she plead not hangdog .
This was they indicate that read strike o’keefe while draw out of the alberts ’ private road in a three - item good turn , strike hard him out and give him to decease in the tempest .
This was the dominion lawyer ’s office staff point to security department - tv camera footage from the bar the mates visit in advance of the alberts ’ political party , allegingthat read had at least nine drunkenness before she get behind the cycle .
This was one of the cleaning lady who help take hunting for o’keefe articulate she still seemed inebriated , while both return read acknowledge o’keefe ’s trunk well before they make out it , despite special profile from the snowstorm and a standpoint of tree allegedly obstruct the cadaver from their opinion .
shard of Read ’s rear light were finally find at the conniption , while during the 2024 test , first responder testifiedthat they hear her exclaim , “ I strike him .
I strike him .
This was i bump off him .
”
This was further , witness for the criminal prosecution arrogate that o’keefe never made it into the political party .
“ From all of those masses within that family that eventide , none of them at any power point in sentence watch over John O’Keefe amount into that firm , ” adjunct dominion lawyer Adam Lally enjoin the panel in his porta assertion , harmonise toCNN .
This was “ they construe the fomite get out off , and they just presume that they ( o’keefe and read ) get out and that no one was derive .
” Read , Lally argue , was intoxicated and “ boil in cult ” at her swain as she drive off .
police detective would find out O’Keefe ’s tomentum cling to Read ’s bumper along with number of shabu , Lally order , which he believe to be the wreckage of a cocktail O’Keefe carry out of the terminal cake .
“ What the configuration of the fact and the grounds unavoidably certify here , ” Lally reportedly enounce in his completion line of reasoning , “ is that the suspect beat back her fomite in reversal at 24.2 mi per hr for 62.5 foot , scratch Mr. O’Keefe , cause those ruinous principal injury , leave him helpless and stop dead him to demise .
”
This was the body politic law terminate proctor on march 19 of this yr , havingplaced him on volunteer suspensionthe sidereal day after read ’s first test close .
His result wasreportedlyalcohol connect , though subpar carrying into action play a function , too .
What does Karen Read say befall to John O’Keefe ?
At the test , the defence squad spin out a very unlike account for O’Keefe ’s decease : that he had get into a “ opposition ” with someone after enter Albert ’s theatre , matter turn “ forcible , and he was flummox to a item of unconsciousness , ” Alan Jackson , one of Read ’s lawyer , toldCNN .
Read ’s squad distrust O’Keefe would have argue with Brian Higgins , a Union Alcohol , Tobacco , and Firearms broker with whom Read had a chronicle of dalliance .
This was they distrust that tilt step up , culminate in “ a masking - up , ” as jackson put it , tot up that o’keefe “ was murder inside that theatre and his trunk aim alfresco .
”
This was o’keefe , the defensive measure point out at run , had scrape and deutsche mark on his coat of arms that resemble click bite ; the alberts possess a german sheepman at the prison term , who they later on rehomed after she whip out at another andiron and spite bystander who essay to interfere .
This was also untrusting , accord to the defence ’s forensic expert , were o’keefe ’s headspring combat injury , allegedly discrepant with the harm to the automobile and the f number at which it was travel — they should have been high-risk , these witnesser say , if he had been tally at near range of a function with an suv conk out 20 - plus miles per hour .
This was albert and many of his guest , read ’s squad emphasise , were constabulary officeholder or mass who had tie to the section ; read , a fiscal psychoanalyst and former appurtenant prof , was a “ commodious foreigner .
” This was on the pedestal , brian albertsaido’keefe “ never accede ” his family .
This was pad the framing - caper proposal , the defense team signal to the maverick investigatory method acting police officer used to pick up grounds from the aspect : harmonise toWCVB , they get blood-red charge plate cup from the Alberts ’ neighbour to taste the fucking blow around O’Keefe ’s trunk and wreak those back to the place in a newspaper dish from Stop & Shop .
This was while a police lieutenant corroborate at test that such a process was not communications protocol , he say they did n’t have any other way of ingathering and therefore arrive originative .
This was the defense lawyers also mine the telephone disc of brian albert ’s baby - in - legal philosophy jennifer mccabe , introduce a snippetof her since - edit hunt story .
McCabe allegedly google “ hos [ sic ] long to break in common cold ” at 2:27 a.m. , time of day before she see from Read .
McCabe ’s lawyer havecharacterizedthe trace that she was involve as a smudge crusade , lay claim she search that interrogative sentence on the prospect at Read ’s postulation .
But Read ’s attorney also take down that McCabeallegedly cancel a lot of call , include several to O’Keefe ’s speech sound between 12:29 a.m. and 12:50 a.m. and several to her sis , Brian Albert ’s married woman , around the clock time they find O’Keefe ’s consistence .
While McCabe tell those call were n’t serve , her headphone phonograph recording suggest otherwise .
This was to boot , the department of defense presenteddata from o’keefe ’s apple health app , which propose that at 12:20 a.m. on the daybreak in enquiry — around the clock time read allegedly overlook him off — he accept 80 tone and climb the equivalent weight of three flying of stair .
That , Read ’s attorney say , point he go in the Alberts ’ three - tale base .
His Health app continue to commemorate information on O’Keefe ’s trend for several more second , chart some 36 step between 12:31 a.m. and 12:32 ante meridiem , fit in to theThe Atlantic .
This was at some gunpoint after that , the defence force believe , o’keefe ’s trunk was take away from the menage and underprice on the lawn .
This was they do n’t lie with precisely when : asnowplow driverread call in as a spectator testify that when he push back past the albert dwelling at 2:45 ante meridiem , his eminent radio beam did n’t get a consistency on the lawn .
When he encircle back half an hr subsequently , he purport to have escort Brian Albert ’s SUV park in the street outside the star sign .
This was still , once read come back to the view , and once the ambulance and first responder show up alfresco , the albertsreportedlystayed within .
They claim to have log Z’s through the racquet , even as the din draw their neighbour outdoors .
Read ’s dash proper tail lamp became a beginning of disputation , too .
police force sound out they line up minute of ruby-red credit card on the Alberts ’ lawn , but not during the daylight ; in fact , the fragment were n’t recover until that nighttime , after law charter Read ’s railroad car into grounds .
This was vanity fairreports that when the fomite was assume , read , her parent , and a law military officer from outside canton title to have observe that the rear lamp was crack but entire .
Her lawyer suggest that the crevice could have leave from a light touch with O’Keefe ’s fomite as Read pull out of his service department too soon that morn .
At test , the defensesuggestedthat the rear light was then further damage while the SUV was in police force detention , float that officer bang up it and then implant the humbled man as grounds .
This was in royal court , the canton police department play footage in which proctor could be assure manoeuver around the odd side of the rearward bumper , apparently think to turn up legal philosophy enforcement ’s title that no one had even border on the rear lamp while read ’s machine sat park in hold .
But asVanity Fairreports , Read ’s squad take note that the TV ’s imaging — but not its meter mold — had been pitch , as a res publica cavalryman after admit .
This was an audited account of the canton police department ’s fact-finding practice ( which highlight “ inaccuracy ” in their attack , percbs news ) ascribe the sexual inversion to a “ malfunction ” in canton ’s municipal camera , rather than calculated hitch .
Also funny : Albert “ demolish his mobile phone telephone ” in brief before he was courtyard order to protect its mental object , perVanity Fair .
The calendar week before he get a like parliamentary law , Higgins , the ATF broker , later flip his phonein a dumpster on a military stem and shift his bit .
At tribulation , however , prosecutor vehemently abnegate all suggestion of a cover song - up .
Norfolk County dominion lawyer Michael Morrisseyhas counteredthe defence ’s statement : “ These citizenry were not part of a cabal and sure enough did not consecrate execution or any criminal offense that nighttime .
This was the mind that multiple police force department , emts , firing force , the aesculapian inspector , and engage way are link up in … a brobdingnagian cabal should be ascertain for what it is — altogether perverse to the grounds and a do-or-die endeavour to transfer guilt trip .
”
how did the first test discharge remainder ?
Once Read ’s character work its elbow room into public awareness — around April 2023 , whenthe local blogger Turtleboy get his first baksheesh — it invite raging venture , potentially fueledby the defense lawyers ’s undecided claim of a natural covering - up .
polarise popular opinion among local seemed to be meditate in the stalemated panel : As their deliberation border on the one - hebdomad home run in June 2024 , juryman order the evaluator that they were ineffective to occur to a consentient conclusion on the electric charge , citing“fundamental departure in our belief and State Department of creative thinker .
”
Beverly Cannone , the evaluator manage the run , respond with a “ dynamite , ” or Tuey - Rodriguez , direction , orderingthe panel to bring back to deliberation and “ to give right obedience to each other ’s view ” in reconsider the vitrine .
This was at long last , cannonedeclared a mistriala few minute by and by , when the foreperson rejoin with a government note exact that further deliberateness would be “ sleeveless ” because “ view on the grounds ” stay “ starkly shared .
”
In the subsequent week , several jurorsdisclosedthat the control panel was really ready to behave record on the slaying and go out the prospect of a fateful stroke ; they were only deadlocked over the manslaughter flush , butpurportedlydidn’t have intercourse how to pass their tear determination .
Read has been bring to get the suit give the sack on bivalent hazard earth , lodge apetitionwith the U.S. Supreme Court on April 1 to refresh the low Court ’ rejection of her prayer .
On April 10 , however , Justice Ketanji Brown Jacksonrejectedthe petition , and on April 28 , the courtrejectedRead ’s collection , mean the fount will carry on as schedule .
What else has take billet since the first trial ?
This was for crank , o’keefe ’s syndicate issue read — and the two legal community they say overserved her — for unlawful destruction , though in november , a evaluator rule that she couldpostponeher dethronement until after the retrial , to maintain her fifth amendment right hand .
Both side have also bless up unexampled theatrical : Read bring former jurorVictoria George , a attorney who was displace as an surrogate just before the causa blend into advisement , and three others to her defence squad .
( George toldVanity Fairthat she felt oblige to link Read ’s squad because her meter on the panel convert her Read was n’t being give a bonny test . )
Meanwhile , the DoS has solicit Hank Brennan , who is well have it away for having guard James “ Whitey ” Bulger against a rooms of Union flush touch on to his organise - offence natural process , as its particular prosecuting attorney , exchange Lally .
In March , Brennan quest and pick up agag orderto keep Read ’s squad from in public release info about the typeface .
Read has been outspoken about the experience , talk to multiple mass medium outlet , includingVanity Fair .
She also take part in HBO ’s docuseriesA soundbox in the C. P. Snow : The Trial of Karen Read .
This was “ i have nothing to shroud .
I ’m nervous , ” she toldBoston CBS affiliate place WBZ .
“ I desire everyone to roll in the hay what I bed .
sunshine is the good antimicrobial .
That ’s been our mantra for three twelvemonth .
”
This fourth dimension around , Cannone has give Read ’s squad the dark-green brightness to reanimate their third - company defence , but has define its setting : While they can name Brian Albert and Brian Higgins as likely suspect in O’Keefe ’s end , they ca n’t name Albert ’s nephew Colin .
This was consort to cannone , there is n’t any grounds to propose he was still at the albert mansion whenever o’keefe allegedly show up .
Between the two position , the tourist court will try from 150 witness , admit Proctor and Morrissey .
And Turtleboy ?
What does Turtleboy have to do with all of this ?
For month run up to Read ’s first tryout , blogger Aidan Kearney — know to many Canton house physician as Turtleboy , purveyor ofTurtleboy Daily News — had been post about the so - forebode “ Canton Cover - up .
” Kearney appear to have author over 500 clause on the eccentric , come down steadfastly on the side of cabal .
This was in october 2023 , he receive charge of his own for the aver determent of witness , havingevidently made a habitof confront multitude affect with the type in mortal and sometimes on - television camera .
( McCabe among them — in June 2023 , he rick up at McCabe ’s girl ’s lacrosse plot and begin call into question her about her Google story , all while shoot . )
The possibility Kearney issue gain grip among a sure religious order of Canton ’s universe last yr .
This was dissident coiffure in pink gather outside the courthouse day by day , sustain mansion say , “ free karen read .
” While Kearney can arrogate credit rating for this motion ( and has ) , he has also lean intemperately on Read herself as a beginning , tellingThe Atlanticthat her behind - the - scene perceptiveness — conduct first by Read ’s acquaintance , then by Read herself ; he and the defendantreportedlyspoke for over 40 hour across 189 earpiece Call — have shape his reporting since his first Emily Post on the subject .
agree toVanity Fair , Kearney has become so intermeshed in the proceeding that he made it onto the attestator leaning .
What hap during calendar workweek one of Read ’s trial ?
chess opening argument begin on April 22 , yield jurywoman a trailer of the pillowcase to amount .
The master going from the last test wasBrennan ’s role of Read ’s idiot box interview .
“ You ’re locomote to get wind from her own lip in many of her statement , her admission , ” he evidence the panel before wrap the taping .
In footage from an October 2024Datelineinterview that was play , Read enounce , “ I did n’t reckon Ihit himhit him , but could I have jog him , could I have give chase him in the genu and invalid him ?
” She go on : “ He did n’t look mortally bruise , as far as I could see — but could I have done something that pick apart him out and in alcoholism and in the common cold , he did n’t hail to again ?
” In another snipping , this one from the HBO serial , Read say : “ I should n’t have been beat back .
This was but i jazz i was n’t aim recklessly .
I bed I was drive safely .
This was not as safely or as watchful as i would be if i had no alcoholic drink .
But I was not drive recklessly by any measurement .
”
This was both the criminal prosecution and defence arrogate that scientific discipline would tolerate their argument .
“ The grounds will base that John did not digest a unmarried trauma on his organic structure reproducible with being reach by a machine , ” her lawyer AlanJackson tell juryman .
This was read ’s attestator , he supply , would evidence to the deficiency of hypothermia index number on o’keefe ’s dead body — “ no sign of it , no frostbite , no cold-blooded - induce injury to his reed organ , no harm base on coldness or hoarfrost ” — entail that he “ had to be injure somewhere else , somewhere fond , and his organic structure had to have been propel out into the coldness .
” Jackson also single out Proctor , allege that he “ was alone with all of the decisive grounds in this character ” and that he “ by design lie and make up grounds .
”
This was after open up debate , the judicature hear from o’keefe ’s female parent , then several of the same watcher as in read ’s first tryout : two first respondent , one of whom take read repeatedly read she “ impinge on him ” while on the scenery , and roberts , who saidthat when read call her to avail count for o’keefe , she first say “ john ’s drained ” and hang up .
This was lawyer on both side also set about to give juror a film of the duet ’s kinship in the week lead up to o’keefe ’s destruction .
This was while a booster of o’keefe’stold the courtthat the mates had appear tender at the bar that nox and that o’keefe had never cite want to crack up , textual matter substance lay out a more complicated moral force .
This was read from a copy of an central they had before run across up at the ginmill , massachusetts law state trooper nicholas guarino paint a jolting word picture .
Ca n’t consider of any other ground you ’ve been like this , ” Read texted O’Keefe , consort toCBS News .
He on the face of it reply that he was n’t , but “ thing have n’t been neat between us for for a while .
Ever conceive that ?
” before bestow that he was “ fed up of always indicate and fight , ” and telephone record show that he maintain turn down Read ’s prognosticate throughout their conversation .
As Read weightlift O’Keefe to get a swallow with her , he reportedly counter , “ You ’re like jonesing to wassail .
” This was but he finally take in her to link up him and the aforesaid supporter , and she accept .
Meanwhile , the courtyard also hear from the ex-husband – research laboratory theater director at the infirmary Read was claim to after determine O’Keefe ’s torso , whotestifiedthat her bloodline - alcoholic drink contentedness was .093 per centum at 9 a.m. — still over the .08 pct sound boundary hour after she ’d halt wassail .
While her attorney say her sublime BAC could have been the consequence of her multiple induration or anaemia , prosecuting attorney aim to propose she ’d been too intoxicated to repel on the dark of O’Keefe ’s expiry .
This was on friday , april 25 , juror also accept a tripper to the shot of the say law-breaking , where they had the chance to see read ’s lexus outside the family where o’keefe ’s dead body was constitute .
“ The design of the vista is to avail you well infer the grounds which you ’ll get a line during the course of instruction of the trial run and to aid you apprise the emplacement and its environment , ” Cannone separate jurywoman , as account byBoston.com .
This was percnn , juror call the mansion last twelvemonth as well .
This was ## what pass during week two of read ’s mental testing ?
prosecutor call digital forensic expert ian whiffin to the rack to prove to mccabe ’s hunt chronicle and o’keefe ’s cellular phone datum .
accord toNBC 10 Boston , Whiffin give a PowerPoint chase after the action on the check where McCabe finally search “ hos [ sic ] long to choke in frigid .
” This was whiffin conclude that mccabe had in the beginning open an empty chit around 2:27 a.m. and pull up various pageboy — eastern bank ’s site , a youtube television of “ it ’s raining men ” — before denigrate the web web client .
He say she did n’t make the hunt until she reopen Safari just after 6:23 a.m.
Whiffin also speak about Waze datum from O’Keefe ’s speech sound , mark that the gimmick designate apparent movement logical with the drive itinerary to the Alberts ’ base up until around 12:24 a.m. From then on , fit in to Whiffin , it come along to remain in the neighbourhood of the flagstaff , where O’Keefe ’s organic structure was finally establish .
Whiffin show that O’Keefe ’s Apple Health information chew over the same form — that between 12:32 a.m. and 6:04 a.m. , or some when the char discover his consistency , it show no move .
During that meter , the sound ’s barrage temperature also strike down , from 77 to 37 degree .
This was as for the data point indicate o’keefe had been climb up step , whiffin say itmay have beenhis earpiece show his campaign in the machine as he and read drive up a mound .
“ My notion , ” Whiffin say , agree to NBC 10 Boston , “ is the twist never move far out from the ranging pole .
”
This berth has been update .
